Pages

5 Sept 2020

Beyond Good and Alcohol

Alcoholic drinks do not agree with me. A single glass of wine 
or beer is amply sufficient to turn life into a valley of tears.

 
Nietzsche didn't just despise the moral narcotic of Christianity; he also hated alcohol and often wrote of the negative effect that booze has on the character.

Thus, although he'd enjoyed a drink or two in his student days, Nietzsche was pretty much a teetotaler all his adult life and insisted that for free spirits, such as himself, a refreshing drink of water was enough (or, on special occasions, maybe a small glass of milk). 
 
Alcohol, he insisted, dulled intellectual and emotional intensity and those who consume it - like the beer-swilling Germans - do so at their peril; they wilfully make themselves stupid as well as obese.      
 
Having said that, it's hard to imagine Nietzsche lending his support to the temperance movement of the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth century, which is clearly a form of finger-wagging puritanism that coincided with Christian revivalism and women's suffrage (something else that Nietzsche was not a fan of).

Thankfully, Nietzsche is liberal enough to call for individual decision making on the basis of personal need, rather than a general prohibition on the production, sale, and consumption of alcohol; for this saves him from falling into fanaticism on the subject.     
 
 

1 comment:

  1. This very much brings to mind the way Lydia Lawrence involved the young D.H. Lawrence and her other children in the Band of Hope temperance movement. Alcohol certainly does (counter-intuitively!) have a depressive effect. It may induce the occasional magical moment - but it is all in all a socially acceptable killer and life is far better and infinitely more authentic (emotionally, intellectually, creatively) without it. Although most addicts will be unable to feel that way about their beloved booze.
    Lawrence's Pansy, "Don'ts", urges us not to "be beholden to the herd inside the pen", to "knock a little hole in the holy prison", and one stanza specifically advises. . .
    "Don't be sucked in by the su-superior,
    don't swallow the culture bait, don't drink, don't drink and get beerier and beerier,
    do learn to discriminate."
    As it so happens, any reader of this post who can reach the Memorial Park in Chapel-en-le-Frith, SK23 0LA by 4.30pm today can hear this poem (and other Pansies) performed in full by a member of The Lawrence Players.

    ReplyDelete