Pages

▼

18 Nov 2026

On Closing the Consent Gap

Logo of the Close the Consent Gap campaign
 
 
I. 
 
Following recent high-profile cases involving young women and older celebrities, there are now calls for greater legal protection for 16- and 17-year-olds. 
 
Indeed, there's even a campaign to close the consent gap which proposes a staggered age of consent and the criminalising of sexual relationships between young adults in this age range and those outside it - particularly those who are significantly older.
 
 
II. 
 
The campaign founder, social worker Layla Stone, insists this is all about safeguarding minors from sexual exploitation. For she and her supporters seem to understand every relationship exclusively in terms of power imbalance. 
 
But one might possibly view it as a form of paternalism (even ageism), based on stereotypical thinking and moral prejudice [1]. Something that not only discriminates against significantly older adults but also fails to respect the bodily autonomy and agency of young people.  
 
Nevertheless, the UK government is said to be considering the idea - the same government, ironically, that is also pushing a bill through parliament that will extend full voting rights to 16- and 17-year-olds, meaning they will be able to choose a political representative, but not a romantic partner more than three years older [2]. 
 
 
III.       
 
As a libertarian, my initial reaction is surely there are enough laws in place already to deal with the sexual exploitation of minors and that the authorities should concentrate on dealing with actual abuse rather than try to police consensual relationships.
 
And, as a Lawrentian, I'm reminded of what Oliver Mellors told Sir Clifford Chatterley: "'Folks should do their own fuckin', then they wouldn't want to listen to a lot of clatfart about another man's'" [3], nor seek to place further restrictions on who can do what with whom, when, where, and how.    
 
 
IV.
 
However, I suppose at some point along the line one has to concede that no individual - and no relationship between individuals - exists in a purely private sphere. No matter how tightly you bolt the door, what goes on in the bedroom is shaped by socio-cultural norms, legal frameworks, and ethical obligations that extend far beyond personal pleasure. 
 
We all have families, friends, neighbours, etc., and what we do - like it or not - affects them. Our choices inevitably draw from - and feed back into - the social fabric. In other words, folks can never simply do their own fucking. We might like to believe our sex life is an intensely personal experience, but it's actually structured by the world we inhabit. And even choosing to transgress laws and taboos is, of course, still to be shaped by them. 
 
Similarly, the attempt by Mellors and Connie to construct a private sanctuary in the woods as a refuge from the world of money and machines is itself a product of modern social pressures - and that's why Bataille is right to point out that the world of lovers is the world of politics [4], and desire is productive of social reality (bringing things and people into touch).    
 
 
V. 
 
Having said that ... 
 
Just because sexual relationships exist within a social fabric, it doesn't mean the criminal justice system needs to poke its beak into the bedrooms of 16- and 17-year-olds in order to check birth certificates, or that campaigners like Layla Stone should be allowed to dictate the law.
 
We can voice concerns and establish norms of behaviour without turning 20-year-olds into sex offenders or stripping young people of their sexual agency. If we can trust them at the ballot box, we can trust them in the bedroom (even if they sometimes vote for a charlatan or sleep with a wrong 'un).  
 
 
Notes
 
[1] I'm aware that advocates of reform frame their concerns around developmental asymmetry and structural vulnerability and would vociferously reject the suggestion that there is any age-based prejudice motivating them. In other words, they would argue disparities in neurobiological maturity, life experience, and financial independence create problematic power imbalances and that's why there's a need to stagger the age of consent. 
      While I don't deny that safeguarding considerations are real, I still worry that treating every cross-generational relationship as inherently coercive, exploitative, and/or abusive is replacing the need for nuanced risk assessment with blunt legal paternalism and prejudice. The fact is, not all young people are vulnerable and not all older people are predatory.  
 
[2] The proposed reform would make it an offence for a person aged 20+ to engage in sexual activity with a person aged 16–17, unless the age difference is no more than three years. And so, 17 and 20 would be legal, as would 16 and 19. But 16 and 20 would be illegal, as would 17 and 21. For further information on the Close the Consent Gap campaign, visit their website by clicking on the link provided at the top of this post. 
 
[3] D. H. Lawrence, Lady Chatterley's Lover, ed. Michael Squires (Cambridge University Press, 1994), p. 268. 
 
[4] See Georges Bataille, 'The Sorcerer's Apprentice', in Visions of Excess: Selected Writings, 1927-1939, ed. Allan Stoekl, trans. Allan Stoekl, with Carl R. Lovitt and Donald M. Leslie, Jr. (University of Minnesota Press, 1985), p. 229.  
 

No comments:

Post a Comment