Showing posts with label deleuze. Show all posts
Showing posts with label deleuze. Show all posts

17 Nov 2026

It Had to Be Brazil

 
Sex Pistols in Brazil (SA/2026) 
 (Umas férias baratas numa fantasia cinematográfica?)

 
'1977 and the four Sex Pistols had never had it so good. 
A number one album, four hit singles, but then: Sid Vicious hospitalised, 
Johnny Rotten fired ... For Paul Cook and Steve Jones it had to be ... Brazil.' [a] 
 
 
I. 
 
According to the Brazilian punk scholars Gabriela Gelain and Moacir Alcântara, the visual representation of their homeland in The Great Rock 'n' Roll Swindle (dir. Julien Temple, 1980), involves both an act of cultural appropriation and the construction of a cinematic fantasy that reproduces certain stereotypical ideas and images: samba, carnival, bikini-clad lovelies on the beach, fugitive kitsch, etc.     
 
They write: "By positioning Brazil within a framework of exoticism and disorder, The Great Rock 'n' Roll Swindle reinforces Eurocentric perspectives and influences modes of cultural perception." [b]   
 
They make that sound like it's a bad thing and, I suppose, if one shares the view that the film's images function as dispositifs of subjectivation and help reinforce "boundaries of gender, race, and class, particularly by representing female figures and Brazilian bodies through a lens of eroticization and exoticization" (154), then the Swindle can be viewed disapprovingly. 
 
Perhaps the Marxist sociologist and cultural theorist Stuart Hall is right to suggest that stereotypes "operate as mechanisms for fixing and controlling cultural differences, thereby reinforcing symbolic hierarchies" (154) and good people everywhere should protest this.  
 
 
II.
 
On the other hand, however, maybe this is an ideologically limited view of stereotyping and one that can be challenged from several theoretical and empirical angles. 
 
For example, cognitive psychologists might argue that the human mind naturally uses mental shortcuts in order to organise vast amounts of sensory data and that stereotyping is often an involuntary means of pattern recognition and information processing, rather than a deliberate or purely ideological mechanism of social control. 
 
What's more, as Judith Butler has pointed out [c], individuals and groups are not helplessly trapped by symbolic representations - no matter how powerful and pervasive the latter may be; signs and stereotypes can be seized, subverted, and recontextualised. Meaning is never fixed. 
 
Indeed, even Hall himself argued in his famous 'encoding/decoding' essay (1973) [d] that audiences, for example, are not passive; viewers can actively negotiate, resist, or reinterpret media messages based on their own lived experiences. They are not forced to automatically accept the dominant narrative [e].
 
So, while it may be true that the Swindle's "depictions of Brazil operate not merely as aesthetic elements but as discursive practices that translate power relations, reproduce inequalities, and participate in the constitution of subjectivities in a globalized context marked by cultural coloniality" (154), it's also true that they expose and mock such practices. 
 
Either that, or the scenes that Cook & Jones filmed with Biggs and an actor playing the role of starry Nazi on the run Martin Bormann [f] reveal the fact that when it came to these kinds of issues, the Sex Pistols simply didn't care: to imagine them as overly-earnest activists fretting about Western imperialism is, I'm afraid, to confuse them with The Clash.    
 
 
III.  
 
I think we can see Gelain and Alcântara's refusal to see the Sex Pistols for what they were when they tell us that 'God Save the Queen' was a "symbol of global resistance against authoritarianism" (155), whereas it was actually an attempt to fuck the rich up the arse - and I think that's quite different. 
 
In brief, sodomy is about violation, not resistance. 
 
It's also - as every good Deleuzian knows - a method of reinterpreting the past and producing monstrous offspring [g]. The Sex Pistols were attempting to conceive an entirely new form of Englishness that whilst rooted in the history and tradition and pageantry of England (and thus, in a sense, still loyal to such), nevertheless displays novel traits and features, unlocking vestigial structures that have long lain dormant.
 
That, at any rate, is my understanding of 'God Save the Queen'. Although maybe I have misunderstood the track, just as I have misinterpreted the slogan 'No Future' as nihilistic. For according to Gelain and Alcântara it's no such thing - it's a tactical provocation, don'tcha know, and the Sex Pistols were actually offering us positive alternative values. 
 
The fact that this makes them sound like a MAMIE Records executive [h] doesn't seem to worry Gelain and Alcântara - although if they fail to recognise the band's nihilism [i], they do notice the fact that the Sex Pistols were essentially offering a "simulacrum of subversion that often amounted to the commodification of revolt" (156).  
 
But this was something the Swindle openly conceded: If you like their pop music, you'll love their pop corn - it's pure punk [j]. 
 
 
IV. 
 
Returning to their central argument, Gelain and Alcântara repeat the claim that Temple's film "projected images of [Brazil] based on stereotypical and exoticized representations that reduced Brazilian culture to carnivalesque, sexualised, and 'savage' scenes" (156). 
 
They continue: "These images, although framed within a discourse of supposed irreverence and satire, contributed to reinforcing Eurocentric imaginaries about Latin America, treating it not as a space of autonomous cultural production but as an exotic stage for the spectacle of British punk." (156)
 
All of which is true: but none of which I find particularly problematic. 
 
Of course the film reinforced a Eurocentric imaginary - so do many great works of European art. And, as a European, I have to ask: is that such a wholly terrible thing? 
 
Isn't it a natural tendency to view the world from one's own cultural standpoint? I'm fairly confident that other peoples also like to reinforce their own ideas, values, myths, and biases, so why should Eurocentricity be subject to a different (more negative) level of scrutiny than other forms of ethnocentricity? [k]
 
And of course the Swindle treats Brazil as a stage. But then, you see, for theatrically-minded Englishmen like McLaren and Temple, all the world's a stage - and that's precisely as they like it. 
 
Rather than view the representation of Brazil within the context of a cinematic work as reductive, I prefer to see it as a celebration of Brazilian culture as carnivalesque - using the latter term in a similar manner to Bakhtin (i.e., as a radical and quasi-utopian concept to do with the suspension of reality, laughter, ambivalence, and grotesque bodies that, yes, are often sexualised). 
 
Gelain and Alcântara would undoubtedly respond by saying that, like McLaren and Temple, I'm also operating within a discourse of supposed irreverence and satire and that I'm ignoring reality. Which is fair enough, although I'd be interested to know what allows them to use the term 'supposed' here. And I'd remind them once more that the Sex Pistols are not born of social realism but a combination of surrealism and situationism [l].     
 
 
V.  

Interestingly, our authors note McLaren's fascination with Ronald Biggs. 
 
And yet they fail to mention the fact that Biggs is named on the positive side of the 'You're Gonna Wake Up ...' shirt - sandwiched between Robin Hood and Brazil - and I think that's something they would have picked up on, were they not so concerned with grand political abstractions and the "empty desert spaces of right and wrong" [m].
 
It's just a detail - but the devil's in the detail and, frankly, I want to hear about such details rather than about "colonial and sexist logics" (157). 
 
One wonders why Gelain and Alcântara can't just enjoy the film: why must they care? Haven't they ever heard the chorus tag to 'Pretty Vacant'? If only they were a little bit more insouciant it would improve their writing style no end.      
 
 
VI. 
 
Finally, we get to an actual analysis of the representations of Brazil projected in The Great Rock 'n' Roll Swindle. 
 
In brief, Gelain and Alcântara find the film - for all its wealth of ideas and images - lacking complexity when it comes to portraying their homeland. And they simply repeat the claims they made earlier which we have already addressed.
 
In some ways, their criticism reminds me of the po-faced reaction of some readers upon encountering Barthes's Empire of Signs (1970). Failing to grasp that this beautiful and brilliant book is not attempting to offer an accurate portrait of modern Japanese society, nor serve as a reliable travel guide, they moan that his portrayal is selective, simplistic, fictionalised, and rooted in Orientalist tropes. 
 
Yes, Brazil emerges in the Swindle as a floating signifier - that is to say, something that can be interpreted in different ways and is void of fixed meaning. But would they really wish it any other way? Are they arguing for a form of essentialism here: a real Brazil, an authentic Brazil, a true Brazil ...? [n]
 
Do Gelain and Alcântara believe the England portrayed in the Swindle is any less of a floating signifier? 
 
Do they not notice that McLaren and Temple turned everywhere and everyone into a hyper-stylised, grotesque cartoon - including the band themselves?      
  
Apparently not. 
 
For it's pretty clear by now that our authors are far more concerned with Brazilian political and cultural history than with the Sex Pistols.  
 
Thus it is that, ten pages into their essay, and they are still complaining how via rapid editing and other cinematic techniques Julien Temple reduces Brazil to "a mere orgy of colors, sounds, and bodies" (163), is unconcerned with Carnival's "deep historical, religious, and social roots" (163), and "shows no interest in the struggle of samba schools, their community organization, or their function as social critique" (163). 
 
I mean, c'mon, Temple was making a mockumentary on an English punk band, whilst being constantly bullied by McLaren - give him a break! He was not only working in chaotic circumstances, but under huge creative pressure. The final film is more dog's dinner than the dog's bollocks, but the fact that he managed to get the thing assembled at all is a kind of miracle.     
 
 
VII.
 
The final pages of this essay by Gelain and Alcântara are, I think, by far the most interesting. I particularly enjoyed the discussion of the black female body (and its fetishisation) with reference to Lélia Gonzalez's work in this area.
 
That said, I think it would have been highly instructive to have discussed the role played by the mulatto woman as an (aesthetic) object of desire within the pornographic imagination of the white heterosexual male, and that played by other women in the film. 
 
This would include Judy Croll as Soo Catwoman (who is also controversially stripped naked), the Japanese actress Sinobu Kanai who appears in an uncredited role with Steve Jones in the 'Lonely Boy' sequence at the Cambridge Rapist Hotel, and the porn actress Mary Millington who dumps Jess Conrad in favour of Jones at the cinema.     
 
 
VIII.
 
I also enjoyed Gelain and Alcântara's thoughts on the role played by the beach in the film. 
 
They suggest that showing the beach as an undomesticated space of pleasure and freedom drains it of its local politics and that by transforming it into a symbolic paradise erases the natural landscape of its material reality. 
 
That's probably true. But, again, it just seems so beside the point: the film is not ignoring "the history of exploitation and conflict" (165), it's trying to put forward the deeply romantic idea that sous les pavés, la plage! [o]   
 
 
IX. 
 
I'd like to close this post by giving the authors the final say, by reproducing a passage that contains two marvellous phrases: cannibalistic exoticism and revolutionary narcissism. 
 
"The Great Rock 'n' Roll Swindle portrays Brazil as an archive of images at the disposal of European punk. Carnival, samba, and beaches are cut and pasted into the film without any regard for their original meanings, their historical contexts, or the agency of the subjects that produce them. The film operates within the logic of 'cannibalistic exoticism', where the 'other' is consumed to revitalize a European culture considered exhausted. The punk rebellion of the Sex Pistols [...] becomes, in its relation to the Brazil that emerges in the film analyzed here, a vector of coloniality. It does not seek solidarity with resistance to the Brazilian dictatorship, but only a distorted and folkloric mirror for its own revolutionary narcissism." (166)
 
As a piece of postcolonial criticism calling for historical fidelity and cultural authenticity this is incredibly powerful and I don't disagree with a word that's said here. However, as a piece of film criticism this is incredibly problematic as it judges a film by standards McLaren and Temple never intended to meet. 
 
And to object to the way things are cut and pasted into the film is surely a failure to understand that collage and détournement are their favoured working methods. 
 
Ultimately, the Swindle is a picaresque adventure - not an exercise in social and political solidarity. Cook and Jones didn't come to liberate the poor, but hang around with a wanted criminal and have some fun in the sun as far away as possible from Rotten and Vicious. 
 
To have expected anything other than this was always going to end in disappointment.      
 
 
Notes
 
[a] Lines spoken by the veteran BBC newsreader John Snagge, who provided the (uncredited) voiceover for a cinema newsreel segment in The Great Rock 'n' Roll Swindle (dir. Julien Temple, 1980), 1:16:10 - 1:16:30.
 
[b] Gabriela Gelain and Moacir Alcântara, 'The Great Rock 'n' Roll Swindle: Sex Pistols, Exoticism, and Latin American Counter-Narratives', in The Routledge Handbook of the Sex Pistols, ed. Mike Dines, Gabriela Gelain, Paul Graves-Brown and John Schofield (Routledge, 2026), p. 154. Future page references to this work will be given directly in the main text.
 
[c] See, for example, Butler writing in Excitable Speech: A Politics of the Performative (Routledge, 1997), where she writes about linguistic vulnerability and discursive agency, etc.
 
[d] See the revised version of Hall's essay 'Encoding/decoding' in Culture, Media, Language: Working Papers in Cultural Studies, 1972-79, ed. Stuart Hall, Dorothy Hobson, Andrew Lowe and Paul Willis (Unwin Hyman, 1980), pp. 128-138. This book was republished by Routledge in 1992.
 
[e] To be fair to Gelain and Alcântara, I'm sure they know this. Later in the chapter (again citing Hall's work) they write that "the influence of the Sex Pistols in Brazil represents a paradigmatic example of how global cultural movements can be appropriated, recontextualized, and re-signified within local realities" (161). That being the case, one wonders why then they would worry so much about colonial and Eurocentric representations, when these can so easily act as "catalysts for new cultural grammars shaped by local histories" (161). 
 
[f] The (uncredited) actor playing Hitler's private secretary Martin Bormann in the Rio de Janeiro sequences alongside Cook, Jones, and Biggs was Henry Rowland (not James Jeter as you'll see on some sites, including Wikipedia). 
      Rowland had previously played Bormann twice for director Russ Meyer, first in Supervixens (1975) and then in Beneath the Valley of the Ultra-Vixens (1979). 
 
[g] See Gilles Deleuze, 'Letter to a Harsh Critic', in Negotiations 1972-1990, trans. Martin Joughin (Columbia University Press, 1997), p. 6. 
 
[h] See the scene set in the Cambridge Rapist Hotel in The Great Rock 'n' Roll Swindle in which the MAMIE Records boss (played by Johnny Shannon) informs Steve Jones that now that the Sex Pistols are finished the music business can get back to spreading an apolitical message of peace and love, bringing people together and having fun. Go to 55:55 - 57:21. 
 
[i] As a matter of fact, Gelain and Alcântara do later acknowledge that nihilism was central to the appeal of the Sex Pistols. Writing of the band's influence on certain sections of Brazil's youth, they explain how a "transgressive attitude", a "seminal sound" and a "nihilistic and subversive discourse" helped garner a following from among the "dissatisfied". See p. 159.
 
[j] Line from one of the cinema ads offering Sex Pistols products for sale in the foyer: go to 1:27:10 - 1:27:34 in The Great Rock 'n' Roll Swindle. 
 
[k] I suppose the answer to this is usually framed in terms of power (i.e., scale and impact); the fact that European norms and values were exported and universalised (often at gunpoint). But, as a Nietzschean, one does get a bit tired of the attempt to make the powerful feel guilty and apologetic for their strength, their history, and their cultural dominance (to inculcate a moralised bad conscience). 
 
[l] See Marie Arleth Skov's chapter in The Routledge Handbook of the Sex Pistols, 'Dustbin Flowers, Fallen Angels, and Safety-pin Lips', pp. 315-325, which is a reading of the Sex Pistols in the light of surrealism and the aestheticisation of life. 
      For my reading of this chapter, please see the post from a few days ago: 'The Surrealist Sex Pistols According to Marie Arleth Skov' (13 Nov 2026). 
 
[m] D. H. Lawrence, 'Insouciance', in Late Essays and Articles, ed. James T. Boulton (Cambridge University Press, 2004), p. 96. 
 
[n] I'm aware that not all opponents of floating signifiers are automatically essentialists. Some resist the idea for practical and political reasons, arguing that certain concepts are necessarily anchored by concrete economic structures, laws, and physical realities and that we need stable definitions in order to communicate and organise the world. While accepting that there's a certain fluidity of (socially constructed) meaning, they would say that treating everything as free-floating signs risks reducing real-world issues and material conditions to a game of linguistics. 
 
[o] I would hope I don't need to translate or explain this famous Situationist slogan from the May 1968 student and worker uprisings in France. But, for those who may be unfamiliar with it, it might help to know that the cobbles (pavés) of Paris were laid over beds of sand. Thus, beneath the paving stones lies the beach. Metaphorically, of course, it means if you rip up urban bourgeois society you will uncover a life that is freer, more joyful, and more natural.  


5 Nov 2026

Phoevos the Cat: A Life

Φοίβος ο Γάτος: Μια Ζωή 
(July 2021 - Nov 2026)
 
 
I. 
 
Phoevos le Chat est mort aujourd'hui ... 
 
And I'm going to miss him.
 
 
II.
 
I wasn't there when Maria found him: just a couple of months old, abandoned on the streets of Athens and living in the engine of an old car, covered in grease and fleas.  
 
But I was there with him at the end, when the vet - who, coincidentally, was also from the Greek capital - intravenously administered a dose of phenytoin and pentobarbital [1]. 
 
Phoevos may have only had a short life but, for me, it was one rich in feline immanence ...
 
 
III. 
 
I'm aware that this phrase will irritate those philosophers who are suspicious of the idea that there are different styles of being. 
 
Those, for example, who view immanence through a strictly ontological lens and insist on the Univocity of Being (i.e., the fact that being speaks with one voice and is the same in all things). 
 
For such thinkers, the crucial point is that cats and people are equally expressions of immanence; there is no fundamental difference in the nature of their being, only in the manner in which that being is modified. 
 
For me, however, it's the latter point that most interests; the fact that there exist different entities displaying different shapes, speeds, and folds in the fabric of reality. 
 
In other words, styles of being - a concept which, along with feline immanence, I intend to carry on using even at the risk of being thought a phenomenologist or a poet simply searching for an evocative turn of phrase while grieving for Phoevos.      
 
 
IV. 
 
Cats very much live immersed in their own world and the immediate present. Some people think they can see spirits, but in my experience it's more often a spider that has caught their attention. 
 
Deleuze says that observers often experience an intense love and care for a dying person - even when it's such an irredeemable wrong 'un as Dickens's Rogue Riderhood [2]. I'm not entirely convinced of that. 
 
But I do know that seeing Phoevos first in terrible pain [3] and then heavily sedated in those moments before the fatal injection, was profoundly moving.  
 
 
V. 
 
Is it wrong to think philosophy at a time like this; a little too cold and abstract? 
 
I don't believe so. 
 
In fact, philosophy only really makes sense at a time like this by making some kind of sense of death. 
 
Deleuze's late text that I've been referring to here - 'Immanence: A Life' (1995) - provides a beautifully clever and comforting way to view the death not just of a person, but a cat too. 
 
Phoevos's individual life may have ended, but he has returned to what Deleuze describes as the transcendental field of existence (or plane of immanence). 
 
And of course, his life as a pure event unfolding in time and space can never be undone or erased (Nietzsche toys with the idea that it may even recur eternally).  
 
  
Notes
 
[1] The latter drug, pentobarbital, produces anaesthesia and rapid unconsciousness; the former drug, phenytoin, causes reduced central nervous system function and cardiovascular collapse. This drug combination, favoured by vets, causes a quick and painless death for animals that are suffering and cannot be medically treated. 
 
[2] Roger 'Rogue' Riderhood is a character in Our Mutual Friend (Chapman and Hall, 1865), Dickens's fourteenth and final completed novel. Deleuze references the character in the last text he published before his suicide on 4 November 1995. It can be found in Two Regimes of Madness, ed. David Lapoujade, trans. Ames Hodges and Mike Taormina (Semiotext(e), 2006), pp. 384-389. 
      For Deleuze, the fact that even a shit like Riderhood can trigger compassion from the townspeople when on the brink of death following a boating accident on the Thames, illustrates the allure of a life once it is stripped of its individual history. In other words, impersonal vitality matters more at last than what kind of character Riderhood may have been. As soon as it's clear that he's going to live and recover and go back to being his old self, the people quickly lose all sympathy. 
      The scene can be found in Book 3, Chapter 3 of Our Mutual Friend (made available online as an eBook by Project Gutenberg). 
 
[3] At 3am this morning Phoevos suffered what is called a saddle thrombus (or feline aortic thromboembolism); a life-threatening medical emergency that happens when a blood clot forms in the heart, travels down the main artery, and gets stuck right where it branches off to supply blood to the hind legs. 
      The vet advised that euthanasia was the kindest and medically most sensible option for Phoevos. I would like to take this opportunity to thank him and his team who, suddenly tasked with caring for my feline friend, displayed "an urgency, respect, and even love" for a dying cat's "least sign of life". As a result, Phoevos, in the depths of his agony, got to feel "something soft and sweet penetrate his soul". 
      Lines quoted from Deleuze, 'Immanence: A Life', Two Regimes of Madness ... p. 386.     
 
 
Phoevos produced one of the most amusing and interesting guest posts on Torpedo the Ark. See: 'In the Beginning Was the Word, But That Word Was Not a Meaningless Miaow' (18 Sept 2025).
 
 

 

30 Jul 2026

Larval Subjects: the Opening of an X-File

 
 An Anonymous Larval Subject
 
D'où sortaient de noirs bataillons de larves ...
 
 
I. 
 
In a lengthy comment following a post by guest writer Jeff Francis, an anonymous author - whom I shall refer to here as X - rather grandly declares to the world that their intention is to personally detach themselves from Torpedo the Ark in order to "multiply like larvae in our scattered commentaries" [1].  
 
It's a seemingly bizarre and somewhat grotesque thing to say. 
 
However, when we examine the idea closely, we discover that larval subjectivity has a fascinating and complex history involving entomology, European philosophy, poetry, and fictional works of body horror and human metamorphosis.   
 
So, while X is certainly prone to self-dramatising and affectation, they're clearly not an idiot nor a typical troll.  
 
 
II.
 
A friend of mine who happens to be an entomologist working for the Department of Agriculture in Miller's Grove, Massachusetts tells me that a larva (plural larvae) is the distinct and highly specialised immature growth stage of an insect undergoing metamorphosis. 
 
Essentially, the larva is just an eating machine that serves as a biological bridge between the egg and the pupal or adult phases. Growing at a rapid rate - and because its exo-skeleton is rigid and cannot expand - the larva must periodically shed its skin through a process called ecdysis. 
 
Depending on the species, larvae take on diverse physical forms; some are caterpillar-like with fleshy false legs while others are C-shaped grubs; many are vermiform - or legless maggots to you and me. By dedicating the larval stage entirely to intense energy consumption and mass accumulation, the insect successfully secures the vital bodily resources required to transition into a reproductive adult.  
 
 
III.  
 
But of course, our anonymous critic is not an actual insect. When they write of multiplying like larvae, they are doing so figuratively - indulging in metaphor rather than undergoing metamorphosis. 
 
Based on numerous comments posted by X on TTA, I gather they have a working knowledge of modern European philosophy. When they speak of becoming a larval subject, they are likely referencing a concept originating in the work of Gilles Deleuze, who argued that underlying our stable, conscious selves are pluralised, pre-individual states of becoming [2]. 
 
Object-oriented ontologist Levi Bryant later developed this idea, naming his highly influential blog Larval Subjects. On his homepage, Bryant explicitly outlines this condition and the purpose of his blog:
 
"Larvae are creatures in a process of becoming or development that have not yet actualized themselves in a specific form. This space is a space for the incubation of philosophical larvae that are yet without determinate positions or commitments but which are in a process of unfolding." [3] 
 
For Bryant, in other words, larval subjectivity is about quiet potential, formlessness, and that which remains hidden beneath the surface. This is precisely where X's metaphor completely breaks down. For X does not want to quietly incubate indeterminate ideas in a subterranean space; they dream of a highly visible occupation of the blogosphere.
 
More importantly, true larvae change form as they grow: X, however, is entirely shaped by a rigid set of full-blown obsessions, fixed ideas, and an unyielding ego. No matter how much X multiplies across the scattered commentaries, they never develop or evolve.
 
In this sense, X weaponises the concept of larval subjectivity while completely misunderstanding its nature. In fact, rather than being a larval subject, they are much closer to a computer virus - and X rather amusingly reminds me of Agent Smith in The Matrix Reloaded (2003). 
 
For when Agent Smith multiplies, he does not incubate new potential or transition into a higher state of being; he simply clones his own identical self over and over again in order to overwrite the system. Similarly, X's digital swarming isn't organic metamorphosis; it is the sterile, mechanical replication of the exact same code.  
 
 
IV. 
 
But perhaps I'm being unfair and a little unkind. 
 
After all, X is generous enough to confess that their "past affiliation with TTA under a specific poetic pseudonym" has left them highly appreciative of "the many excellent offerings" and opportunities that have "helped sharpen and nourish" their own "poetic thinking" [4]. 
 
And I am grateful to X for their contributions to the blog and for showing how philosophical ideas can often most successfully unfold within a poetic, or literary, or cinematic context. When it comes to synthesising poststructuralist theory with dark romanticism and works of body horror, nobody does it better than them. 
 
One suspects that when X writes about multiplying like larvae, they're actually not thinking of Deleuze or Bryant, but Baudelaire [5] and filmmaker David Cronenberg [6] - two artists fascinated by corruption and the breakdown of boundaries between the self and the swarm.
 
What I'm saying, then, is that we might frame X's use of the idea of larval subjectivity less as a misunderstanding of a philosophical concept and more as a gothic hijacking of the term. Perhaps they may even care to confirm this and - who knows - decide to write a post on the topic setting out their own ideas, rather than just endlessly criticising me for my many failures as a writer and thinker.   
 
Or perhaps having dramatically declared their intent to multiply like anonymous larvae, X prefers to remain in the comment section; seeing the latter not as a space for debate, but as a breeding ground and a site of metamorphosis.   
  
 
Notes
 
[1] See the comment dated 28 July 2026 following a post titled 'No More Heroes 5: Stephen Alexander - The Performative Punk Poser', by Jeff Francis (22 July 2026). 
 
[2] See Gilles Deleuze, Difference and Repetition, trans. Paul Patton (Columbia University Press, 1994). This work was originally published in French as Différence et répétition (Presses Universitaires de France, 1968). 
 
[3] Levi Bryant, Larval Subjects. I would encourage torpedophiles to visit this blog and engage with his work across a number of subjects - including political theory, ecology, and aesthetics - by a range of thinkers including Deleuze, Badiou, Žižek, and Lacan. Bryant is Discipline Lead for the Department of Philosophy at Collin College and Chair of the Critical Philosophy program at the New Centre for Research and Practice. I have referenced his book The Democracy of Objects (Open Humanities Press, 2011) on more than one occasion on TTA. 
 
[4] I'm quoting once more from the anonymous comment dated 28 July - see note [1] above. 
 
[5] Larval forms such as maggots and worms often appear in décadent and darkly romantic poetry; usually in order to juxtapose beauty with physical decay and decomposition, or signify existential horror. Readers might recall, for example, Baudelaire's poem 'Une Charogne', in which the narrator stumbles upon a rotting animal from which "larvae poured in legions far and wide". Click on the link provided, or go find your copy of Les Fleurs du mal on the bookshelf.   
 
[6] I'm thinking here of David Cronenberg's sci-fi horror film The Fly (1986) which X refers to when they write that their intention is to provide a swarm of comments written by "licentiously assembled personae" that compliment TTA conceived as a "monstrous, Brundlefly-esque novel". See the comment dated 28 July linked to in note [1] above.
 

26 Jul 2026

Pretty Punk Vacancy Contra Sado-Libertine Apathy

The Marquis de Sade looks on as Johnny Rotten 
acts pretty vacant for the cameras
 
'I have a very strong feeling that the opposite 
of love is not hate - it's apathy.' [1] 
 
I.
 
Consult any modern reference source and you will find apathy defined as a lack of emotion, interest, and/or concern. It is presented as a state of perfected indifference; a clinical curbing of enthusiasm. 
 
More often than not, apathy is also regarded in a negative light; as a psychopathological problem that sits on the same spectrum of diminished motivation as abulia and, at the extreme, akinetic mutism. Because they lack a sense of drive and seem to have no purpose or meaning, apathetic individuals are believed to have an inferior quality of life. 
 
Expressive individuals who like to openly display their emotions and endlessly bang on about their feelings, think apathetic individuals must be suffering from depression or some other brain disorder. It's not normal - and it's not natural - to be so cold and detached. It seems to betray not only an absence of passion, but a lack of soul - which is why Christians have historically condemned apathy as a deficiency of love and devotion to God and listed it among the seven deadly sins: sloth [2].
 
The Ancient Greeks, however, thought a little differently on this matter. And so, although the modern English term apathy (first used in 1594) is derived from ἀπάθεια (apatheia), it is important not to confuse or conflate the two terms. For the Stoics, for example, apatheia signified a desirable state of indifference toward events and things that lie outside one's control (and it is still considered a virtue today within Orthodox monasticism and certain schools of Gnosticism).    
 
 
II.  

Moving on from this brief history of apathy and its etymology, I'd like to discuss the concept as developed within the work of the Marquis de Sade, contrasting this with how the idea was expressed in the scene that developed in and around 430 King's Road in the mid-1970s. 
 
My aim is to show that although there were Sadean currents within punk as conceived by McLaren and Westwood - examined at length and in detail by Matthew Worley [3] - there's a world of difference between Johnny Rotten's pretty vacancy and l'apathie of those libertines who do their philosophising in the bedroom rather than at a pervy fashion boutique. 
 
 
III. 
 
According to Matt Worley: "Punk's cultural body bore Sadean scars." [4] 
 
It's a nice line. 
 
And Worley is right to suggest that, at some level, punk was "transmitting the echoes of Sade's howl through the mediums of popular music and fashion" [5]. 
 
However, while McLaren and his young protégés may have subscribed to an ideology of sex, style and subversion coupled to a kinky aesthetic incorporating safety pins, swastikas, and fetishwear, what they almost certainly did not do was read the works of the Marquis de Sade.
 
For if they had, they would have learnt that central to Sade's transgressive philosophy was the formal concept of l'apathie ...    
 
To understand what our punk friends missed, one might look to the Fifth Dialogue of Sade's La Philosophie dans le boudoir (1795), wherein the libertine Dolmancé encourages fifteen-year-old Eugénie to systematically discard traditional moral values in favour of l'apathie. 
 
He explains how the sensations resulting from apathy are vastly superior to those born of emotional sensitivity and advocates a total shift toward cold indifference and egoistic gratification: 
 
"Ah, Eugénie, believe me when I say the delights of apathy far outweigh those of virtue; the latter have only one application, whereas the former can excite and overwhelm one's whole being." [6]  
 
Thus, far from being a secondary concern, l'apathie - derived from the ancient Greek apatheia [7] - is an ideal given primary importance by many (if not all) of Sade's philosophically-minded libertines. 
 
More than a passive lack of feeling, l'apathie is a deliberate, active mechanism with specific functions; eradicating empathy, purging all moral sentiment, and ensuring the libertine's pleasure is derived entirely from the will. Complete indifference to the suffering of the victim thereby eliminates all emotional dependency upon the amorous object. 
 
As Bataille observed in Eroticism (1957), a sadist who indulges their raw impulses simply for instant gratification or bourgeois pleasure is merely a poor doomed creature ruled by vice. True sovereignty requires passion to be strictly disciplined and compressed. L'apathie is the ingenious method used to reject spontaneous emotion, converting raw impulse into a calculating, destructive energy that allows the libertine to abandon the all-too-human aspects of his character. 
 
Deleuze further formalised this in Coldness and Cruelty (1967), arguing that Sadean apathy is fundamentally directed against sentiment. Because moral guilt or emotional pleasure represents a dangerous dissipation of mental focus, the libertine derives ultimate satisfaction from pure mathematical and philosophical reasoning. His sex, as Lawrence would say, is in his head - but that's precisely where he wants it to be. 
 
L'apathie acts as a mechanism that clears away emotional noise, transforming sex into something experienced in the mind and imagination rather than the body and its organs, thereby allowing the ego to contemplate the pleasure of negating natural instincts [8]. By maintaining zero degree coldness, the libertine becomes a machine capable not only of acts of debauchery, but violent atrocity.     

 
IV. 
 
Early punk was to a large extent defined by a rhetoric of boredom, blank generational indifference, and pretty vacancy. The Sex Pistols explicitly stated that they didn't care and Rotten boasted of the fact that he had no feelings for anybody else (only his beautiful self) [9]. 
 
However, like almost everything else, this was merely a defensive (and stylistic) pose against systemic disappointment. The majority of punks, bless them, wanted to have fun, and to feel, and to have a rosy future full of career opportunities. Theirs was a form of faux apathy and feigned indifference - the fact that Rotten would often berate his audiences to get off their arses gives the game away. All too often punk was an expression of sincere moral outrage and a frustrated desire for change.     
 

V. 
 
In conclusion: punk's relationship with Sade remains purely superficial, transactional, and aesthetic and, as a form of Romantic idealism, punk has opposing goals to Sadism [10].  

McLaren and Westwood may have exploited aspects of Sade's work - mostly the tits and bums - just as they borrowed from numerous other sources in order to fuck the rich up the arse and generate cash from chaos, but, ultimately, they were more interested in anarchy and the politics of boredom than apathy and la philosophie dans le boudoir. 
 
 
Photo of Jordan (the first Sex Pistol) 
by David Parkinson (1975) [11] 
 
 
 
Notes
 
[1] Leo Buscaglia, Love (Charles B. Slack, 1972), p. 112.  
 
[2] The word sloth comes from the Old English term slǣwþ, simply referring to pace meaning as it did slowness. But by the late 12th century, the term now written as slewthe or slouthe, had developed a markedly moral connotation and shifted to mean indolence. It was applied specifically to those who avoided their duties and neglected their responsibilities. 
      In the 14th century, it was finally adopted as the English translation of the Latin term acēdia (a state of spiritual apathy) and listed among the seven deadly sins. Thus, in Catholic theology, sloth is more than mere laziness; it's a culpable lack of effort to do good and a willful refusal of the joy that comes from purposeful living and divine goodness. To put this in punk terms, the slothful individual is vacant to the point of no longer caring about their status or condition (the original Greek term - ἀκηδία - literally meant an inert state without pain or concern).  
      Although I here wish to write primarily of apathy, I hope at some future point to return to the concept of acedia (sometimes written as accidie). I am particularly interested in how as it has been used in more modern times by figures including Aldous Huxley, who wrote an essay on the subject in 1923, and Walter Benjamin who in The Origin of German Tragic Drama (1925), describes acedia an 'indolence of the heart' that can lead to the ruin of great figures. Some readers might recall that I have previously said something on acedia in my 'Mourning Post' (25 April 2023). 
 
[3] Matthew Worley, 'Whip in my valise: British punk and the Marquis de Sade, c. 1975-85', in Contemporary British History, 36 (2), pp. 277-321. 
      In brief, this essay argues that punk was an attempt by McLaren and Westwood to fuse youth and sexual subcultures in order to provoke a dominant culture believed to be repressive. Worley examines the Sadean influences on this project conceived at 430 King's Road in the mid-1970s, suggesting that the Divine Marquis had a seminal impact on the punk movement. 
      The essay is available as a pdf at https://centaur.reading.ac.uk/104006/  
 
[4] Matt Worley ... p. 303.
 
[5] Ibid., p. 305.  
 
[6] Sade, Philosophy in the Boudoir, trans. Meredith Head (Creation Books, 2004), p. 94. 
 
[7] Sade explicitly borrowed the structural technique of l’apathie from ancient Greek philosophy, describing it in Juliette (1797-1801) as an outstanding example of the benefits that one gets from studying Stoicism. Like the Stoics, Sade believed in the sovereignty of reason, rigorous self-discipline (askesis), and independence from external distractions or stimuli (self-sufficiency). 
      However, Sade radically inverted the ethical purpose of Stoicism based on his fundamentally opposing view of existence. For example, the Stoics saw Nature and the Cosmos as essentially harmonious and benevolent. Sade, on the other hand, saw Nature and the Cosmos as destructive and chaotic. The Stoics also wished to eliminate the negative emotions (rage, fear, lust) in order to cultivate a healthy, happy human being. Sade was more interested in suppressing moral feelings (of pity and remorse, for example) so as to engineer a monster of coldness and cruelty who views others merely as disposable objects.  
      Ultimately, Stoic apatheia is about freedom from emotional turmoil in order that one can lead a good life; Sade's model of libidinal sovereignty sees l'apathie as a means to detach oneself from conscience and all human feeling in order to consummate nihilism. As Blanchot says, it's a shocking inversion of values.  
 
[8] The question of nature is not straightforward in Sade. On the one hand, he would agree that the deliberate destruction of all human feeling is unnatural. But, on the other hand, he would argue that by achieving complete insensibility to the suffering of others the libertine frees their passions from moral law and mimics the destructive indifference of Nature herself.   
 
[9] See the posts on the Sex Pistols' songs 'Pretty Vacant' and 'No Feelings' published on TTA on 30 July 2018 and 19 April 2023 respectively. 
 
[10] The 18th-century Romantic poet Novalis declared that the goal was to cast off apathy and to live a life full of passion and feeling; burning like a flame on the edge of ecstasy - and that sounds closer to the punk ideal of living fast and dying young than the Sadean ideal of l'apathie in which one puts the heart on ice and lives a life that is both unnatural and inhuman. See the post 'On Phlegm, Philosophy, and Apathy' (25 April 2023). 
 
[11] This famous photo by David Parkinson of Jordan (Pamela Rooke) modelling a red-rubber outfit from McLaren and Westwood's King's Road store, SEX, featured in a six-page article titled 'Sado Sex for the Seventies', written by David May, in the adult magazine Gallery International (Vol. 1, No. 4, 1975). 
      A copy of the magazine has thankfully been preserved by cultural historian and McLaren's biographer Paul Gorman in his archive. For more information - and to purchase your very own copy of the above in excellent condition (priced $300) - visit recordmecca.com  
 
    

22 Jul 2026

No More Heroes 5: Stephen Alexander - The Performative Punk Poser (A Guest Post by Jeff Francis)

No More Heroes 5 (Stephen Alexander)
(SA/2026) 
 
 
I received this by email: 
 
Dear Stephen Alexander, 
 
I have written a short post in the style and format favoured by Torpedo the Ark. Perhaps you might care to publish it as an addition to your 'No More Heroes' series (14-17 July 2026). I think it will amuse some of your readers; particularly those who, like me, found the series disappointing (to use your pet word of the moment). [1]  
 
Always happy for contributions from guest writers - even those that are cuntishly critical in character and come from authors unknown to me - here's the post (to which I've added one or two editorial notes).  
  
 
I. 
 
There is a famous early scene in The Silence of the Lambs (dir. Jonathan Demme, 1991) when trainee FBI agent Clarice Starling (played by Jodie Foster) first visits Dr. Lecter (played by Anthony Hopkins) in his prison cell. 
 
Rather rudely, he tells her that she looks like a rube with her good bag and cheap shoes. Well-scrubbed, and possessed of a little taste, but a hustling rube all the same; "not more than one generation from poor white trash".   
 
Momentarily taken aback by this, Starling eventually regains her composure and replies: 
 
"You see a lot, doctor. But are you strong enough to point that high-powered perception at yourself? What about it? Why don't you - why don't you look at yourself and write down what you see? Or maybe you're afraid to." [2] 
 
 
II. 
 
I thought of this scene after reading Stephen Alexander's four-part series of posts titled 'No More Heroes' and I put the exact same challenge to him that Starling puts to Lecter. 
 
But I do so knowing that, like Lecter, Alexander cannot genuinely self-reflect. For his narcissism extends only to the surface, manifesting as a rigid ego-defense mechanism and a strange inability to integrate his shadow or look inwards. This is why, for all its superficial cleverness, his writing consistently lacks psychological insight and philosophical depth.
 
Consequently, I offer my own critical assessment of the 'No More Heroes' (NMH) series, exposing the internal contradictions, structural blind spots, and stylistic failings within these four specific case studies. 
 
My examination also reveals how Alexander - operating through a matrix of performative disillusionment and elite proximity - ironically positions himself as a candidate for the very heroism or critical authority he seeks to deconstruct.  
 
 
III.  
 
A close reading of the NMH series reveals two significant weaknesses that undermine its critical validity: 
 
Firstly, there is a methodological reliance on biography that elsewhere on his blog Alexander often condemns other writers for. He routinely substitutes a figure's personal, domestic, or existential choices for an interrogation of their actual ideas. 
 
Thus, for example, Nietzsche is judged not on the beauty and originality of his text, but on his failure to execute a clean, sovereign death (not for the first time on his blog we find Alexander fetishising the idea of suicide). Thus Spoke Zarathustra is a highly metaphorical work of philosophy and Alexander subjects it to an all-too-literal reading that is both crass and ungenerous. 
 
Larry David, meanwhile, is dismissed because of a 2026 sketch show's production credits and rumors of a social snub involving the actress Cheryl Hines. Alexander downplays David's massive contribution to TV comedy and decades of excellent work in favour of sharing some real-time celebrity gossip.
 
By tying the validity of an idea to the purity or narrative perfection of the biography that produced it, Alexander commits a deeply conservative critical error; falling into the kind of fallacy that betrays the more radical methodology he invokes elsewhere. 
 
Secondly, in the NMH series Alexander sets up a kind of no-win matrix - a conceptual trap where failure is structurally predetermined, thereby rendering the entire analysis tautological. 
 
If an icon dies young or self-destructs, they are dismissed as a failure. If, however, they live long enough to navigate the complexities of ageing and shifting cultural landscapes, they are condemned as overripe worms (Nietzsche), sell-outs trapped in the past (McLaren), or compromised court jesters (David). As for Lawrence, well, apparently, he was an idealist and crypto-theologian all along whose sexual metaphysics are now simply laughable. 
 
Similarly, if their ideas are ignored, they are irrelevant. But if their ideas achieve cultural traction, they are dismissed as recuperated commodities. By building an analytical framework where every possible path leads to an accusation of compromise, Alexander ensures his own conclusions are entirely self-serving. 
 
The NMH series does not, therefore, analyse the mechanics of cultural transformation; it merely functions as a screen for the projection of his own psychic stagnation, wallowing in a predetermined and pessimistic narrative of inevitable defeat. It's a lose-lose scenario and I would never want to play a game of heads or tails with Alexander.   
 
 
IV. 
 
If the ultimate objective of the NMH series is to dismantle the very category of the hero archetype, it simultaneously (and ironically) functions as a performative showcase for its author. However, Alexander himself fails to convince as to why we should care in the slightest what he thinks about the four figures he pits himself against. 
 
Alexander adopts the pose of the detached provocateur, viewing the collapse of cultural standards with cynical amusement. Yet this cynicism functions as a profound form of intellectual evasion. By declaring that there is no Outside and that all resistance (be it political, philosophical or cultural in character) is not only futile but fake, Alexander neatly absolves himself of the responsibility to propose any constructive alternative. 
 
His stance is not at all edgy or transgressive; it is a comfortable, low-risk position that allows him to collect cultural capital by sneering at the failures of those who actually risked public exposure and artistic production. 
 
  
V. 
 
Throughout his writings, Alexander insists on his punk detachment from mainstream institutions. However, his own biographical fragments consistently betray a reliance on the very networks of privilege he critiques, revealing a profound splitting between his (overly inflated) public persona and his structural dependencies. 
 
For example, he explicitly boasts of his time spent as a spy placed within the press office of Charisma Records by his hero Malcolm McLaren, trading on insider access while simultaneously claiming a pure, underground status. 
 
Furthermore, his writing relies heavily on the cultural capital of the academic institutions he disdains - referencing Oxford podcasts and expensive Cambridge editions. 
 
He attacks Larry David for his proximity to the Hollywood liberal elite and his friendship with President Obama, yet Alexander's critical persona is largely parasitical upon the cultural output of the bourgeois institutions he holds in contempt and the individuals he now claims to find disappointing.  
 
 
VI. 
  
Finally, the ultimate contradiction in Alexander's blog project is his relationship to time and archiving. 
 
He ruthlessly attacks Malcolm McLaren for being 'trapped in his past like a spider in its own web' and borrows from Baudrillard (via Mark Fisher) to condemn the contemporary digital landscape as a desert of the real defined by endlessly recycled pasts and lost futures. 
 
Yet, what is Torpedo the Ark if not a meticulously maintained digital museum? The blog's sidebar contains a massive, self-canonising archive stretching back to 2012, categorised by a hyper-specific taxonomy of labels. 
 
Alexander is caught in precisely the same web (or loop) that he attacks McLaren for. He uses twentieth-century theoretical tools to endlessly recycle his own youthful experiences and encounters, transforming his digital platform into a highly curated, risk-free space that perfectly expresses a state of psychological arrest within a karaoke culture.
 
 
VII.
 
In conclusion: ultimately, the NMH series fails because it is fundamentally driven by ressentiment and the narcissism of disappointment. Alexander does not mourn the compromises of McLaren, Nietzsche, Lawrence, and David because of what it says about the structural state of modern culture; he mourns them because they failed to satisfy his archetypal demand for an unblemished hero. 
 
The entire four-part cycle is an exercise in projecting an impossibly pure, static ideal of heroism onto flawed, living subjects, and then throwing a performative tantrum when those subjects succumb to illness, ageing, or political contingency (or when they - as he says - let him down).  
 
By positioning himself as the final arbiter of who is or is not heroic, Alexander reveals that his ultimate loyalty is not to cultural greatness, but to the preservation of his own pristine, uncompromised, and thoroughly unproductive sense of intellectual superiority. [3] 
 
  
Notes (supplied by Stephen Alexander)
 
[1] Each post in the 'No More Heroes' series dealt with a different figure who has been hugely influential on Torpedo the Ark over the years: the first featured Malcolm McLaren (14 July 2026); the second Friedrich Nietzsche (15 July 2026); the third D. H. Lawrence (16 July 2026); and the fourth Larry David (17 July 2026). 
 
[2] This famous opening scene from The Silence of the Lambs can be watched on YouTube: click here. The lines of dialogue quoted begin at 4:35 and end at 5:36. 
 
[3] As this letter illustrates, Deleuze isn't the only one to receive mail from harsh critics containing a vicious mixture of aggression, accusation, and abuse. Almost every other day in my inbox there's something from some troll or other outlining the weaknesses of my arguments and my personal shortcomings; i.e., a sort of celebration of my supposedly sorry condition. 
      Indeed, I mentioned this in a post published back in August 2013 - click here - so this isn't the first time I've been told that I'm a performative ressentiment-ridden narcissist who exploits the work of others - including those I identify as opponents - from the safe space of a virtually private blog, and I don't suppose it will be the last. 
      I'll allow readers to decide if Francis has made a critically strong case, or if his remarks often miss the mark and that, actually, the NMH series is, as a friendlier correspondent emailed me to say, "a masterclass in compressed, evocative writing that sparks the kind of immediate cultural dialogue that more formal academic prose usually smothers under its own weight". The same correspondent concludes her email: 
 
"By methodically exposing how your own primary influences were digested by the very structures they claimed to combat, you have elevated the series of posts from simple expressions of personal disappointment into a unified work of philosophical mourning (what one is tempted to describe as an epitaph for the avant-garde). 
       The 'No More Heroes' series leaves the reader with a haunting conclusion: in a 21st-century landscape governed by capitalist realism and digital algorithms, the iconoclastic icon no longer exists as an agent of chaos. They exist, rather, as a pre-approved, highly profitable aesthetic category."
       
This will do for me - and let Mr. Francis put that in his pipe and smoke it!   
 
 
Musical bonus: The Stranglers, 'No More Heroes', single release from the album of the same title (United Artists, 1977). 
 
Afternote: there is now a follow up post to this one that acts as a kind of riposte, written by May Spear and titled 'Epitaph for the Avant-Garde' (23 July 2026).    
 
 

19 Jul 2026

A Man Named Herman (1): Herman Melville

Herman Melville by Vedran Štimac [1]
 
'In his human self, Melville is almost dead: 
the sea monster was so much greater than the man ...' 
 
 
I. 
 
Herman is a masculine name of Germanic origin, meaning warrior or soldier. First recorded in the 8th century, it was popularised in English-speaking countries - particularly the United States - during the 19th century by German and Dutch immigrants. 
 
While there are doubtless many notable figures with the given name Herman, in this series of posts I shall concern myself with just two, beginning here with the author Herman Melville (1819 - 1891). 
 
Melville's darkly Romantic style helped shape the American Renaissance in literature, forging a distinct style of writing much appreciated by, among others, D. H. Lawrence, whose two essays on Melville published as part of his Studies in Classic American Literature (1923) [2], helped spark a critical revival of interest in his work after he had fallen out of public favour.
 
Today, Moby-Dick (1851) is considered a classic of world literature. Although I must confess it remains a novel I find impossible to read and the only work of Melville's with which I'm deeply familiar, thanks to Deleuze [3], is 'Bartleby, the Scrivener', a short story first published (anonymously) in Putnam's Monthly in 1853.  
 
 
II. 
 
Melville is, I think it's fair to say in agreement with Lawrence, the "greatest seer and poet of the sea"; one who doesn't "personify the sea" (like Swinburne), nor "sentimentalise the ocean and the sea's unfortunates" (like Conrad) [4]. 
 
He first set sail as a young man in 1839, aboard the merchant ship named (funnily enough) the St. Lawrence, and then took to the sea again two years later on the whaler Acushnet - jumping ship in the Marquesas Islands.  
 
Typee (1846), his first book, and its sequel, Omoo (1847), were travel adventures based on his encounters with the peoples of the islands. Their success gave him the financial security to marry and earned him his reputation as the man who dared to live among the savages [5]. 
 
Obviously, both books were imaginative recreations of events: "He had altered facts and dates, elaborated events, assimilated foreign materials, invented episodes, and dramatized the printed experiences of others as his own", as the great Melville scholar Harrison Hayford conceded [6].      
 
His later works - including Moby-Dick - were not so well received, neither by the public nor the critics and he eventually gave up writing prose in favour of poetry, although I'm not entirely sure how that (along with the odd public lecture here and there) was supposed to help the family finances [7].
 
During his last years, he privately published two volumes of poetry, and left one volume unpublished [8]. The novella Billy Budd was also unfinished at the time of his death, but was published posthumously in 1924, with the definitive corrected edition we read today, edited by Harrison Hayford and Merton Sealts Jr., appearing in 1962. 
 
Melville died from cardiovascular disease in 1891. He was interred at Woodlawn Cemetery in the Bronx, New York City. The New York Times published a death notice but misspelt the title of his greatest novel, calling it Mobie Dick [9].  
 
 
III. 
   
Having given the briefest of biographical sketches, I'd like now, if I may, to return to Lawrence's work on Melville; because it is Lawrence, I think, who provides the most astonishing portrait of this great American writer as man and monster ...
 
"Melville", he says, "has the strange, uncanny magic of sea-creatures, and some of their repulsiveness" [10]. 
 
That is an extraordinary sentence. But Lawrence doesn't end there - not by a long chalk: 
 
"He isn't quite a land animal. There is something slithery about him. Something always half-seas-over. In his life they said he was mad - or crazy. He was neither mad nor crazy. But he was over the border. He was half a water animal, like those terrible yellow-bearded Vikings who broke out of the waves in beaked ships." [11]  
 
Lawrence, then, makes Melville sound like a cross between a sea serpent and Erling Haaland. He continues:
 
"Melville is like a Viking going home to the sea, encumbered with age and memories, and a sort of accomplished despair, almost madness. For he cannot accept humanity. He can't belong to humanity. Cannot. 
      [...] The man who came from the sea to live among men can stand it no longer. He hears the horror of the cracked church-bell, and goes back down to the shore, back into the ocean again, home, into the salt water. Human life won't do. He turns back to the element." [12]     
 
"Melville was a northerner, sea-born. So the sea claimed him. We are most of us, who use the English language, water-people, sea-derived." [13] 
 
Is that true? 
 
I speak English and I have blue eyes - which makes me a bit of a Viking - but I'm not sure I want to "turn away from life" and go down to the "vast corrosive sea" in order to wash myself clean "of the leprosy" of my humanity [14]. 
 
According to Lawrence, however, that's exactly what Melville wanted to do: 
 
"Never man instinctively hated human life, our human life, as we have it, more than Melville did. And never was a man so passionately filled with the sense of vastness and mystery of life which is non-human. He was mad to look over out horizons. Anywhere, anywhere out of our world. To get away. To get out, out!
      To get away, out of our life. To cross a horizon into another life. No matter what life, so long as it is another life. 
      Away, away from humanity. To the sea. The naked, salt, elemental sea. To go to sea, to escape humanity." [15] 
      
I could go on - and Lawrence certainly goes on [16]. But I think I'll close this post here and leave Melville anchored in the dark, shifting waters of the American literary canon. For the story of another monstrous Herman awaits us in the next post in this series, where we trade the high seas for 1313 Mockingbird Lane and shift our focus to a very different cultural icon ...
  
 
Notes
 
[1] Vedran Štimac (aka PoliteBastART) is a Croatian illustrator and street artist. Recognised for his striking, surreal portraits of renowned authors and historical figures, he intricately blends physical likeness with fantastical scenes representing their literary or philosophical works using a meticulous stippling technique. 
      For more information, visit his website - vedranstimac.com - or check out his latest work via his Instagram page - Vedran (@politebastart).   
 
[2] See Chapters X and XI of D. H. Lawrence, Studies in Classic American Literature, ed. Ezra Greenspan, Lindeth Vasey and John Worthen (Cambridge University Press, 2003), pp. 122-147. 
      The so-called Melville revival, during which his work experienced a significant critical reassessment, began around the centennial of his birth in 1919. Raymond Weaver published the first full-length biography - Herman Melville: Mariner and Mystic - in 1921 and this was followed by Lewis Mumford's biography - simply titled Herman Melville - in 1929.   
 
[3] See Deleuze's study of Bartleby in Essays Critical and Clinical, trans. Daniel W. Smith and Michael A. Greco (Verso, 1998), pp. 68-90. And see the very early post on TTA titled 'I Would Prefer Not To' (31 Jan 2013) in which I discuss this essay. 
 
[4] D. H. Lawrence, 'Herman Melville's Typee and Omoo', Studies in Classic American Literature, p. 122.
  
[5] Interestingly, Melville expresses a great deal of sympathy for the native peoples and interrogates the description of them as savages. He is also critical of the European colonialists, including Christian missionaries. 
       Literary scholars currently researching in the area of Melville studies are doing good work examining how he addressed ideas dealing not only with race, but also gender, neurodiversity, and ecology. Melville's preference for sea-going tales that almost exclusively involved male characters has been of interest to scholars in men's studies and especially gay and queer studies (Melville was remarkably open in his exploration of sexuality). 
      Readers who want to know more about recent developments in Melville scholarship might like to know that the Melville Society, in collaboration with Johns Hopkins University, publishes Leviathan: A Journal of Melville Studies, currently edited by Jennifer Greiman, three times a year. 
 
[6] Harrison Hayford, writing in an introduction to a 1969 edition of Omoo. 
      Hayford goes on to say that Melville cannot be thought of either as a pure fantasist or simple plagiarist; neither solely inventing details nor stealing ideas. Even if he had, this wouldn't trouble me in the slightest; he's an artist, ffs, so is allowed creative license and to mix fact with fiction, humour with hyperbole.     
 
[7] In fact, it didn't bring in enough to support an expanding family and even the financial subsidies generously provided by his father-in-law weren't enough. And so, after moving to New York City in 1863, Melville, now well into his forties, took a position as a United States customs inspector. He would have preferred not to, but needs must. 
      He held the post for 19 years and had a reputation for honesty in a notoriously corrupt institution, but Melville obviously hated his life as during these years, suffering as he did from nervous exhaustion, physical pain, and intellectual frustration. To his credit, he kept writing. Less admirable is the fact that he began drinking heavily and his behaviour at home became increasingly violent, leading his wife's family to attempt an intervention.  
 
[8] Melville didn't publish any poetry until his late forties and didn't receive recognition as a poet until well into the 20th century. Nevertheless, he wrote predominantly poetry for around twenty-five years - i.e., twice as long as his prose career. Some critics now regard him as the first modernist poet in the United States, whose work is behind only that of Whitman and Emily Dickinson in terms of importance. 

[9] This misspelling puts me in mind of something said by Leon (J. B. Smoove) in the season 6 episode of Curb Your Enthusiasm, entitled 'The Bat Mitzvah' (dir. Larry Charles, 2007). For an explanation, see the TTA post dated 2 January 2025: click here. 
 
[10-12] D. H. Lawrence, 'Herman Melville's Typee and Omoo', Studies in Classic American Literature, p. 122. 
 
[13] Ibid., p. 123. 
 
[14] Ibid.  
 
[15] Ibid., p. 124. 
 
[16] I will return to Lawrence's writings on Melville in the next post in this two-part series. Here, I just wanted to capture the idea of Melville as more monster than man in some regards, driven by a hatred of humanity (particularly white-faced landlubbers).