Showing posts with label vivien goldman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label vivien goldman. Show all posts

1 Nov 2026

Reflections on the Museum of Youth Culture Exhibition 'God Save the Queens' & How You Too Will Learn to Live the Lie

Flyer for the God Save the Queens exhibition 
 
"The exhibition challenges traditional punk narratives by placing the women 
who helped shape the movement at the centre of the story: not as 
footnotes to punk history, but as some of its defining creative forces." [1]
 
 
I. 
 
Last week I went to a private viewing of the current exhibition showing at the Museum of Youth Culture [2]. God Save the Queens brings together rare and previously unseen artwork, photography, and personal archival material celebrating the women who shaped punk's look, sound, and cultural history.  
 
The exhibition is curated by Up Yours! - a non-profit, multimedia and art collective founded by Celeste Bell and others [3] to honour punk rock's female pioneers, who are now characterised as she-punks, whereas, back in the day, they were known by the rather less savage and much prettier sounding title of punkettes [4].
 
According to the Up Yours! mission statement, the aim is to "preserve, celebrate, and spotlight the under-appreciated music, literature, film, fashion, and visual art of women who shaped punk and DIY counterculture over the last 50 years". 
 
Which is all very admirable, though I would challenge the premise that the role played by women in punk - and the artwork produced by them - has been underappreciated or overlooked. It's Westwood, not McLaren, whom the fashion world idolises and I would suggest more people are familiar with the faces of Jordan and Soo Catwoman than those of Cook and Jones.     
 
 
II. 
 
But let's not quibble on this point. It's clear that the curators of the exhibition are pushing this tired narrative and continue to derive a certain amount of speaker's benefit [5] from it, so good luck to 'em! 
 
What concerned me more is how the show recreates a boring class system, with all the stars and usual suspects given centre stage (or, in this case, wall space). Meanwhile, actual punk youth is tokenistically given a couple of small boards on which to share their images and stories. For me, this goes against the punk ethos where 'anyone could be a Sex Pistol' and the audience mattered as much - if not more - than the performers.
 
In other words, my real issue with God Save the Queens is how easily a counterculture built on the erasure of hierarchy has been restratified [6] and - what's that word the Situationists liked to use? - ah yes, récupérated [7]. And recuperated with the curatorial connivance of the children of the punk revolution!   
 
 
III. 
 
Having said that - and here's the twist - I enjoyed the exhibition and because I wanted to memorialise an old friend, I even have a photo included in it myself [8]. And so I am, arguably, at some level complicit with - or at the very least caught within the wheels of - the culture industry's recuperative nostalgia. 
 
Similarly, thanks to my involvement with the Punk Scholars Network and the Subcultures Interest Group, I'm an uneasy collaborator with the academic recuperation of punk [9].
 
As The Pop Group once sang: We are all prostitutes / everyone has their price ... And we shall be hypocrites, hypocrites, hypocrites [10]. 
 
 
Notes
 
[1] This quote is taken from the exhibition's promotional material and curatorial statement, framing God Save the Queens as a radical reclamation of space. As we shall see, the reality on the gallery walls tells a somewhat different story. 
 
[2] Just a few minutes' walk from Camden Road station, the Museum of Youth Culture moved to its now permanent location at 51 St. Pancras Way, London NW1 in June of this year, after operating previously as a pop-up museum in various temporary spaces. 
 
[3] Filmmaker and writer Celeste Bell is the daughter of Poly Styrene, which explains why the exhibition is primarily dedicated to the legacy of the late singer, songwriter, and frontwoman of X-Ray Spex. Ms Bell co-founded Up Yours! with Lauren Estelle Jones (yes, Mick's daughter) and the writer, musician and punk professor Vivien Goldman. 
      While Bell and Jones cannot help being the children of punk royalty, we cannot ignore how this lineage grants them the institutional access and cultural authority to determine the narrative. The paradox of an egalitarian counterculture being archived and gatekept by a hereditary hierarchy is central to the exhibition's structural tension. 
 
[4] The term she-punk was coined by Helen Reddington and later popularised by Vivien Goldman as an alternative to punkette and is presumably meant to sound a bit more spiky and savage, although it does make me think of Jennifer Walters and we might question this rejection of the feminine diminutive form; does it mark a victory for women or might it not be seen as an unintended reinforcement of the masculine? 
 
[5] This phrase, coined by Michel Foucault, is a critical component of his critique of l'hypothèse répressive. In brief, certain groups and individuals love believing they have been repressed and marginalised because it yields le bénéfice du locuteur - that is to say, an immediate emotional and political reward that one receives simply by daring to speak openly about a taboo subject or some past injustice. In this case, the Up Yours! Collective want to pretend they are defying the patriarchy and refusing to be silenced - as if they are outside of power and ushering in a liberated and more diverse, equitable, and inclusive future. And they do so with the kind of moral solemnity that some of the original punks would have been appalled by.  
      In sum, speaker's benefit gives the gratification of feeling like a rebel simply by talking about something that power structures and institutions actually want you to talk about and provide the material resources that enable you to do so. See Michel Foucault, The History of Sexuality 1: The Will to Knowledge, trans. Robert Hurley (Penguin Books, 1998). 
 
[6] The sociological concept of restratification refers to the process of a movement such as punk shifting from a flat, egalitarian ideal back into a strict hierarchy. According to Robert Michels, there is an iron law of oligarchy determining this outcome. 
      Thus, as we see at the God Save the Queens exhibition, there are professionally taken photographs of punk icons (the creators and trendsetters) individually framed and carefully hung on the walls, signifying that the subject has cultural value and historical importance (not to mention aura and agency). And then there are snapshots of punk fans (the consumers and fashion followers) randomly collaged together on boards so that their individuality is reduced and they serve only to provide a little authenticity to the event. 
      Of course, to be fair to the curators, there was always a punk elite and in order for a museum to put on an exhibition of something as chaotic as punk they have to make it intelligible to a viewing public and so naturally apply their own bureaucratic (and commercial) metrics; identify the leaders and the marketable faces, etc. 
 
[7] Recuperation is the process by which politically radical ideas and images are co-opted and commodified by the powers that be, thereby neutralising them. In this case, it's the appropriation of punk (and youthful rebellion) by the culture industry. 
 
[8] The picture is of Lorrie Millington - see the sister post to this one titled 'Lorrie and the She-Punks' (30 Oct 2026). 
 
[9] See the post titled 'On Torn Edges and the Need to Archive' (25 March 2024) in which I share thoughts on the PSN. And to access a number of posts that detail my involvement with SIG and its annual publication SIG News go to torpedotheark.blogspot.com/search/label/subcultures%20interest%20group 
 
[10] Lyrics from 'We Are All Prostitutes', by The Pop Group, (Rough Trade, 1979).  
 
 

30 Oct 2026

Lorrie and the She-Punks (In Memory of My Beautiful Friend)

Lorrie Millington 
Artist, Model, Dancer, Writer
 
 
It's vital to remember those whom we have loved: and to love those whom we remember. 
 
So I am grateful to the curators of the God Save the Queens exhibition currently showing at the Museum of Youth Culture for affording me the opportunity to include the above photograph of Lorrie Millington taken in a time that is now long ago, but not quite lost. 
 
Displayed in the company of many other young women that the Up Yours! Collective insist on calling she-punks [1], I hope she feels she is among friends. 
 
Some of these women are famous, some anonymous; some dead, some still alive and kicking. But all are beautiful in the eyes of their friends and family who remember them.
 
 
Typical Girls [2] on a display board 
at the Museum of Youth Culture
 
 
Notes
 
[1] The term she-punk was coined by Helen Reddington and later popularised by Vivien Goldman as an alternative to punkette and is presumably meant to sound a bit more spiky and savage, although it does make me think of Jennifer Walters and we might question this rejection of the feminine diminutive form; does it mark a victory for women or might it not be seen as an unintended reinforcement of the masculine? 
 
[2] The link is to the single by the Slits of that title, released from their debut album Cut (Island Records, 1979). 
 
 
For a rather more critical engagement with the God Save the Queens exhibition, please click here.
 
 

28 Jan 2026

Bob & Vivien & Nick & Young: Thoughts on a Post Screening Discussion

L-R: Nick Egan, Vivien Goldman, Bob Gruen, and Young Kim
Malcolm Mclaren: Worlds End Paris Catwalk Shows 
+ Duck Rock Post Screening Discussion and Q&A 
Click here to watch on YouTube 
 
 
I. 
 
If I could have been anywhere in the world this week it would have been New York City - despite the subzero temperatures - in order to attend a programme of events put on by the Anthology Film Archives to honour Malcolm Mclaren and organised in collaboration with Young Kim, his creative and romantic partner for the last twelve years of his life and the executor of his estate. 
 
Essentially a series of screenings, the week-long event explored McLaren's relationship to film and surveyed his rarely seen or discussed contributions to the world of the moving-image.
 
Following the screening of a 60 minute video of the Worlds End Paris Catwalk shows (1981-84) and the 42 minute long-form music video made to accompany the album Duck Rock (1983), there was a post-screening discussion and Q&A moderated by the the British writer, musician, and punk scholar Vivien Goldman and featuring the American photographer Bob Gruen and the English visual artist and self-styled creative vandal Nick Egan, alongside Young Kim. 
 
And, having now twice watched a recording of this discussion uploaded to YouTube, I thought I'd share some thoughts (and impressions) on what was said (since I wasn't invited to attend and chip in my tuppence ha'p'orth in person). 
 

II.

Vivien Goldman sounds fun and seems keen to infuse a little liveliness into events, which is what you need, I suppose, from a moderator. Her remark re Malcolm's heavenly status (0:26) made me smile; for if he has indeed ascended to the Kingdom of God then the angels had better tie him to a tree, or he'll begin to roam and soon you know where he will be.  
 
Young sounds smart and serious, though one might raise an eyebrow at some of her claims; was Duck Rock really an 'anthropological study of world dance cultures' (3:22)? I mean, it's more than just an amusing pop record, but that's over-egging the pudding somewhat.
 
Let's just say rather that it's an imaginative and pioneering work of ethnomusicological curation - albeit one that conveniently and commercially packages things for a Western audience. Malcolm certainly did his research and Duck Rock displays creative genius, but he wasn't an attempting a serious study of world music nor trying to faithfully document such.          
 
 
III. 
 
It's interesting to hear it confirmed by Kim that there is, in fact, not a huge archive of material left behind by McLaren (6:41); I know some people like to think he was England's Andy Warhol [1], but here he absolutely differed from his hero. 
 
For Warhol, of course, left behind an outrageously large and detailed archive of material, consisting of approximately half a million objects, including his personal and artistic belongings from the 1950s until his death in 1987, and filling a space of some 8,000 cubic feet. 
 
Amusingly, The Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts donated the vast majority of this material to The Andy Warhol Museum, giving them the Herculean task of cataloguing the contents (whilst they hold on to the massive collection of paintings, drawings, and prints).        
 
One suspects that the Malcolm McLaren Estate will soon exhaust whatever materials have not yet been placed into the public arena and that defending his legacy will be Kim's main role, rather than adding to it in any significant manner. 
 
 
IV.     
 
Nick Egan I'm always going to think fondly of, as he was kind and helpful to me back in 1983 [2]. 
 
But his claim that Malcolm was 'not a nostalgic person' (7:11) is laughably false; his entire project might be summed up as an attempt to live yesterday tomorrow (to reverse the past into the future). 
 
He may have been quickly bored and always looked to radically shake up the present (his history in relation to 430 Kings Road is evidence of that), but McLaren was a man haunted by ghosts and childhood memories his entire life and was even nostalgic for mud; i.e., some form of primal and primitive authenticity.  
 
Let's just say that his relationship with nostalgia was complex and that he viewed the lost promise of the past as potentially subversive rather than something to get sentimental about.     
 
 
V.  
 
Bob Gruen - whom I've never met or had any contact with - seems like a nice chap and I enjoyed listening to his anecdotes from back in the day, be they about the New York Dolls or suckling pigs (15:30). 
 
And his initial impression of McLaren as odd (9:45) is not wrong; Malcolm was nothing if not an odd duck, although some may prefer to idiomatically label him a queer fish. 
 
Either way, Malcolm was a member of the punk 1% - i.e., those who don't fit in and don't care (as it says on a Seditionaries shirt) [3].  
 
 
VI. 
 
Interesting also to hear from Nick that Malcolm had 'a bubble around him' (17:37) and wasn't always aware that other people didn't see things as he saw them and didn't always realise when he had overstepped the mark or outstayed his welcome. 
 
Hearing how he managed to piss off the mountain folk in Tennessee (16:42) reminds one of that time when, in 2007, he managed to antagonise the good people of Gardenstown, a small fishing village in Aberdeenshire, by informing them that Jesus Christ was a sausage [4].   
 
Is this a sign of McLaren's egoism, or narcissism, or solipsism ...? 
 
I don't know. 
 
But let's call it innocence. 
 
 
VII. 
 
Interestingly, in answering an audience question about accessing the McLaren archive Kim - who obviously has legal control - makes it clear she also wants complete control. Thus, whilst she plans to make Malcolm's work available, it will be at a time of her choosing and according to the terms and conditions she sets: 
 
'I don't really want [things] just everywhere right away. I want to do something with them, but I want to control kind of how it goes out to be honest.' (30:00 - 30:15) 
      
That's understandable, I suppose, but one does have concerns that Kim is also trying to determine the critical reception of McLaren's work and coordinate his entire story from her perspective (I suspect this is what Vivien Goldman refers to as Kim being a 'really fierce defender' (1:31) of Malcolm's legacy.   
 
 
VIII. 
 
Where Young is spot on - and right to contradict Egan - is in her claim that Malcolm always viewed things ultimately from a British perspective (33:13); thus, for example, his album Paris (1994) was very much a love letter to the city and to French pop culture written by an Englishman.     
 
He once told me that Paris is for living in; New York is for playing in; but London is where he always returns to work and bring ideas together (and it's Highgate, of course, where he has his final resting place, not Père Lachaise).   
 
 
IX.
 
Is Nick right to argue that Duck Rock has had more influence than Never Mind the Bollocks, Here's the Sex Pistols (1977) (41:02)?
 
Young looks as if she wants to interject and challenge the idea and, if I'd been there, I think I might also have challenged that. For while both albums are seminal works, the comparison is inappropriate (maybe even odious), for their influence operates in very different spheres. 
 
Push comes to shove, however, I think Never Mind the Bollocks is the more culturally significant and broadly influential work, having defined the punk movement and its global aesthetic - but this is not to deny or downplay Duck Rock's innovations and the latter album has perhaps proven to be more prophetic (some critics arguing that it not only brought hip-hop into the mainstream, but that it anticipated developments in the 21st century, such as sampling, for example). 
  
 
Notes
 
[1] See the post titled 'The Talented Malcolm McLaren and the Visionary Andy Warhol' (21 Jan 2026): click here. 
 
[2] See the post titled 'Memories of a Duck Rocker' (17 Mar 2025): click here. 
 
[3] I'm referring to the Anarchist Punk Gang' shirt designed by McLaren and Westwood for Seditionaries c. 1979. Click here to view an example of such held by the Met Museum. And click here for a forthcoming post discussing the shirt and in praise of the 1% who don't fit and don't care. 
 
[4] See the post titled 'Don't You Know Jesus Christ is a Sausage?' (18 April 2020): click here.