Showing posts with label wholeness. Show all posts
Showing posts with label wholeness. Show all posts

10 Nov 2026

On Brokenness (And Why I Don't Support Reform UK)

The Reformer - Newspaper of Reform UK 
Issue 001 (Autumn 2026)  
 
 
I. 
 
Saying something is broken means it is damaged, or no longer functioning properly. 
 
And many things can be broken: bones, bottles, hearts, promises, laws, etc. 
 
Even silence.
 
 
II.     
 
But if you're Nigel Farage, then the word broken is a potent political metaphor designed to induce public anxiety, assign blame to opponents, and justify urgent policy intervention and radical structural change. 
 
When Reform UK declare that Britain is broken they are, therefore, following a tried and tested populist script that serves several strategic functions.  
 
 
III. 
 
Obviously, I'm not the first to notice the irony of this: that in order to successfully sell a message of national renewal, they must first wage a campaign of national demoralisation. 
 
I believe this is known as patriotic pessimism - love your country, but acknowledge it's gone to the dogs: crumbling public services, rising crime, spiralling prices, and - of course - record levels of illegal immigration.   
 
By highlighting these (and other) issues, the Reform rhetoric seeks to create a sense of crisis. Britain is broken - but it was broken not by the hardworking people of Britain who pay their taxes and watch GB News, but by the political elite and their friends in the mainstream media. 
 
I know all this because I have just had Issue 001 of The Reformer (Autumn 2026) pushed through my letterbox (not at my request I hasten to add) and the phrase Broken Britain appears repeatedly throughout - as well as in big bold letters on the front page, so readers cannot possibly miss it.   
 
 
IV. 
 
Obviously, it's not a message that appeals to someone like me - someone, that is, born of a critical and artistic tradition where the idea of brokenness enjoys a highly privileged and positive status. 
 
I regard the ideal of Wholeness as a dangerous and totalising fantasy - particularly when invoked in a political context to enforce conformity. For me, freedom and beauty reside (if anywhere) in the crack, the fissure, and the fragment: I still believe in the ruins and I still regard the break not as a sign of failure, but as an opening through which new forces can emerge. 
 
Farage and his Reformers don't seem to appreciate that the history of a people or nation is never complete or settled and never follows a smooth, continuous line of progress. 
 
As Benjamin said, it's not our grand monuments and great institutions that speak of who we are - our true character is only revealed when these structures fall into ruin and our task is no longer to fix that which is broken, but to build up new little habitats and find new little hopes as we move among the ruins. 
 
Or, if we do repair that which is broken, let us do so with gold, so that the break is not disguised or mourned, but celebrated (the Japanese call this the art of kintsugi (金継ぎ).   
 
 
V.
 
It's not my job to tell anyone how to vote. 
 
But I would be wary of any political party that bangs on about a broken nation and exploits the nostalgic longing for a mythic, unbroken past where everything worked perfectly and everyone was united.
 
Das Ganze ist das Unwahre, as Adorno once put it [1]. 
 
And a world without cracks leaves no room for failure, difference, or becoming.  
 
 
Notes
 
[1] This famous line by Adorno - in which he inverts Hegel - reads in English: 'The Whole is the false.' It can be found in Minima Moralia: Reflections on a Damaged Life, trans. E. F. N Jephcott (Verso, 2005), see Pt. 1, § 29. The original German text was published in 1951.   
 

25 Apr 2019

On Holism and Anti-Holism



Despite what some commentators suggest, I wouldn't describe myself as a reductionist.

But, as might be imagined, my love of cracks, gaps, fragments, ruins, ruptures, breakdowns, and all those things that belong to what might be termed a gargoyle aesthetic, means that I have little time for those monomaniacs who subscribe to holistic thinking and insist on a smutty state of Oneness in which all parts are reconciled and find their completion. 

Thus, it's mistaken to read the multiplicity of posts on this blog and then attempt to understand them as a Whole: the will to a system, says Nietzsche, betrays a lack of integrity.

Ultimately, I'm sympathetic to Blanchot's suggestion that we learn to think about the relationship between literary fragments in terms of sheer difference; as things that are related to one another only in that each of them is unique and without, as Deleuze and Guattari note, "having recourse either to any sort of original totality (not even one that has been lost), or to a subsequent totality that may not yet have come about".

In a passage that captures perfectly the anti-holistic spirit of Torpedo the Ark as desiring-machine, the latter write:   

"We live today in the age of partial objects, bricks that have been shattered to bits, and leftovers. We no longer believe in the myth of the existence of fragments that, like pieces of an antique statue, are merely waiting for the last one to be turned up, so that they may all be glued back together to create a unity that is precisely the same as the original unity. We no longer believe in a primordial totality that once existed, or in a final totality that awaits us at some future date. We no longer believe in the dull grey outlines of a dreary, colourless dialectic of evolution, aimed at forming a harmonious whole out of heterogeneous bits by rounding off their rough edges. We believe only in totalities that are peripheral. And if we discover such a totality alongside various separate parts, it is a whole of these particular parts but does not totalize them; it is a unity of all of these particular parts but does not unify them; rather, it is added to them as a new part fabricated separately."

In addition to the artistic implications of this, a number of logical, ethical, and political consequences also follow; ones that, to me at least, appear far more attractive (and more radical) than those that follow on from holism which, unfortunately, is a concept invoked here, there, and everywhere within contemporary culture - even by people who should know better (i.e., people with the ability to be critically self-reflective).

We hear about holistic models of everything; healthcare, education, science, spirituality, etc. Even politicians talk about the need for joined up government. Again, to quote Nietzsche: I mistrust all systematisers - but today it's become impossible to ignore them.

These advocates of holistic thinking speak in fuzzy terms about inclusion, integration, and harmony. But such idealism builds churches and concentration camps; it erases real difference, fears otherness, and ultimately wants to subordinate the individual to a superior Whole (the Party, the State, Humanity). 

I find the thought of One Love, One World, One People, nauseating. If this makes me a reductionist, or a nihilist, then so be it ...


See: Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari, Anti-Oedipus, trans. Robert Hurley, Mark Seem and Helen R. Lane, (University of Minnesota Press, 1983), p. 42.